RDR2 Legendary Fish Guide 2025
Discover the ultimate angler's challenge in Red Dead Redemption 2 with legendary fish across five states, featuring rare species and expert tips for success!
Even after six years since release, Arthur Morgan's legendary fish quest remains one of Red Dead Redemption 2's most captivating challenges! 🤯 With 15 total legendary species in the compendium but only 13 freely catchable outside missions, becoming the ultimate angler requires serious dedication. Forget Jeremy Gill's bragging rights – this is about conquering nature's rarest aquatic beasts across five states! 🌄🎣 Grab your special lures though, because these monsters don't surrender easily...
🐟 Legendary Bluegill
Where: West of Rhodes, Scarlett Meadows facing Flat Iron Lake
Lure: Special Lake Lure
This absolute UNIT dwarfs regular bluegills! Surprisingly chill fight though – perfect for beginners. Pro tip: park near Braithwaite Manor for scenic sunset fishing vibes. 
🎯 Legendary Chain Pickerel
Where: Dakota River NW of Flatneck Station
Lure: Special River Lure
19 inches of shimmering beauty! Cast near Horseshoe Overlook's rushing currents. Careful with the reeling rhythm – its thrashing spikes tension fast.
🌫️ Legendary Bullhead Catfish
Where: West of Sisika Penitentiary, Lemoyne swamps
Lure: Special Swamp Lure
Secret pro move: Borrow a boat near Saint Denis docks! Avoid prison guards by staying west of restricted zones. Murky waters? Perfect camouflage for this slippery beast.
⚠️ Redfin Pickerel Alert!
Where: Stillwater Creek, West of Thieves Landing
Lure: Special River Lure
EPILOGUE ONLY! That invisible sniper near Blackwater insta-kills Arthur. 🔫 But oh, those crimson fins! Small size = easy reel-in once you finally access New Austin.
| Fish | Location Danger | Must-Have Lure |
|---|---|---|
| Rock Bass | Tall Trees sniper ☠️ | Special Lake |
| Largemouth Bass | New Austin chaos 🌵 | Special River |
| Smallmouth Bass | Owanjila serenity 💧 | Special Lake |
👁️ Legendary Rock Bass
Where: Aurora Basin, West of Manzanita Post
Lure: Special Lake Lure
Those haunting eyes! But seriously, AVOID pre-epilogue – Tall Trees' sniper ruins everything. Survival tip: Fish at dawn when predators roam less.
💥 Legendary Largemouth Bass
Where: San Luis River SE of Lake Don Julio
Lure: Special River Lure
Brace yourself for WWE-worthy fights! 🤼♂️ 20+ pounds of pure muscle. Yet the real villain? Bounty hunters swarming New Austin. Save this trophy hunt for John's era.
🏆 Smallmouth Bass Glory
Where: Owanjila Lake, West of Strawberry
Lure: Special Lake Lure
50 INCHES LONG?! This legend demands horse bragging rights. 🐴 Calm waters = easier catch, but bring stamina tonics – reeling takes ages. Photo op essential!
☠️ Elysian Pool's Rotting Perch
Where: West of Butcher Creek
Lure: Special Lake Lure
Pollution created this nightmare fish! Discolored scales and zombie eyes... perfect metaphor for Dutch's decaying gang? Deep lore aside – just hold your breath near those foul waters.
🚂 Saint Denis Surprise
Where: NE of Shady Belle by train tracks
Lure: Special River Lure
Who knew railroads hid freshwater giants? Sturgeon's spiked spine demands heavy-duty reeling. Canoe access recommended for island spots. Dutch hates civilization? This fish proves wilderness survives everywhere.
💎 Steelhead Trout Majesty
Where: West of Willard's Rest, Roanoke Ridge
Lure: Special River Lure
That waterfall backdrop! 💦 Sapphire-scaled beauty worth Murfree Brood risks. Fish upstream from Brandywine Drop – the currents help tire it faster. Arthur's crowning angler achievement? Absolutely.
Still think virtual fishing sounds boring? Try landing ONE without snapping your controller! 😤 Every legendary catch whispers RDR2's untamed magic... So saddle up, partner – which scaley trophy will YOU chase first? Drop your epic fish stories below! 👇 #RDR2MasterAngler